The taste was succulent, sweet and deeply rich at the same time, abundant with essential lake flavors. This isn’t the prettiest fish so you may be surprised at how nice it tastes. I haven't eaten walleye for quite a few years,but my saugeyes do taste very good.Pretty close! Maxximus Redneckus 586 Posted October 21, 2010. If I know the fish might taste a little more "fishy" as do the larger northerns, I do a bake with boneless fillets. Walleye is not only quite tasty – but it’s quite good for you, too. The fat will always taste "fishy", and in some waters it will taste like the dominant forage. Relevance. 118 keeper saugeye in the last 3 weeks! Punching yourself right in your dong is perfectly legal but not the smartest decision. More importantly, you’ll be able to tell them apart next time you catch one. 6 Answers. Don’t let the government make all your decisions for you. It’s generally best to broil it or pan fry it, you’ll note the very mild fishy flavor and … Walleye is also a good source of healthy fats or omega-3 fatty acids. It contains a valuable source of protein, which, as you know, is necessary to build and repair various parts of the body. They taste good, but cleaning them is a pain! I usually don't take fish home though. The worst came from my old home water, Lake Sakakawea. We will eat Walleye any way we can, but it you fry it in beer batter, we’ll eat until we’re sick. Favorite Answer. Just keep the eaters and let the trophys go to grow. Some of the best walleye I've eaten came from small waters where the forage was largely crayfish. Sauger and Walleye are both great fish to catch. Which one do you prefer to catch, Sauger, Walleye, or Saugeye? Walleye Taste. But when I got back to Ohio and tried to replicate my fresh walleye … Anonymous. 0 1. I ate two large fillets. I eat every walleye that’s legal. Walleye is pretty bland and I've only had a few that picked up a bad flavor over the years. What does walleye taste like? On top of that, they both taste delicious. Is it good? Anonymous. If I had a to choose, I would just keep a few bass, crappie, or walleye for eating. The walleye flesh was actually light pink. To many of us, walleye is the best tasting fish. 5 years ago. tj. Walleye is a fresh water fish. I have a couple of different recipies that hide that well. 1 decade ago. 0 0. These are necessary to boost your brain development and support good heart health. Hopefully, you now have a better idea of where both species live. The big ones taste just as good as the small ones. Answer Save. It's a fish. I've never caught a sauger. Which one do you think tastes best? Source(s): The forage thing can be good or bad. 4 years ago. Omg do they ever taste great. When the waitress came by with more, I couldn’t resist helping myself again—it was that good. I cant belive im saying it but I would take a northern fillet over walleye all most any day of the week. I agree that Tilapia is great. Tastes like perch. Does it taste like tuna or shrimp or sea bass? Quote; Link to post Share on other sites. How does walleye taste?